Hi brentadler,
welcome to RuneAudio.
It took me two hours to figure out the Rpi could see networks with SSID names that were incompatible. I needed to remove an apostrophe from the name. Yes ALL non-letter or number characters are a problem.
With my latest
image for RP2/3 this shouldn't be a problem.

- wifi!.jpg (116.89 KiB) Viewed 2107 times
Frank