by vshk » 16 Apr 2017, 03:37
by hondagx35 » 16 Apr 2017, 11:03
I would like to learn from your experience and opinion on which type of streaming is better on the setup below:
by vshk » 16 Apr 2017, 14:35
hondagx35 wrote:Hi Victor,I would like to learn from your experience and opinion on which type of streaming is better on the setup below:
I think you can't compare these two things because they are a totally different approach.
With your option 2 you would not need RuneAudio at all.
A Raspberry Pi with MPD and upmpdcli installed would be enough.
by westrock2000 » 17 Apr 2017, 16:31
by vshk » 18 Apr 2017, 07:23
westrock2000 wrote:You mean playing local content versus "casting" content?
You would have to know how (if) the content is altered by the streaming protocol before being sent....like how Bluetooth does.
You are also limited to 9-10MB/s over the network. If that matters with DSD. I don't think it should.
by hondagx35 » 18 Apr 2017, 23:16
I'm not sure if runeaudio (running on the Raspberry) is treating them as local content when I go for the network mount option.
For the option of using DLNA (UPnP), I guess it is casting(streaming) but I have no idea how the content is altered under this kind of protocol.
by vshk » 19 Apr 2017, 01:45
by medoc92 » 21 Apr 2017, 04:04
vshk wrote:Thank you Frank,
So it sounds the option of using network mount is guaranteed, while using streaming with uPnP may have some uncertainties.
That said, if there is no other special reason of using the DLNA server/client, going for network mount is the better choice.
by vshk » 21 Apr 2017, 08:58
medoc92 wrote:Just to add a few precisions:
- Neither network access methods (NFS/SMB or HTTP) will change anything to the streams. The bluetooth allusion by someone earlier was irrelevant, bluetooth streaming is a completely different thing.
- DLNA servers do not alter the audio except if they are explicitely set for transcoding.
- The audio is played by MPD in both cases, so the volume issue is exactly the same for both.
- There is no setting in upmpdcli which would alter the sound (upmpdcli does not even touch the audio stream).
This said, the network mount is the simpler approach, which leaves you with less to worry about . The advantages of the UPnP setup are having a choice of Media Server (different cataloging approaches), ease of multiple access and choice of control point (remote), none of which may be of interest to you.